Tom Buchanan: Wealth, Power, & Impact in Gatsby

Tom Buchanan, a figure emblematic of the entrenched elite, embodies the reckless exercise of inherited wealth, a defining characteristic within the social strata depicted in The Great Gatsby. His imposing stature and aggressive demeanor serve as physical manifestations of his dominance, a power further amplified by his Yale education and the societal advantages it confers. Daisy Buchanan, his wife, becomes both a symbol and a casualty of this power dynamic, illustrating the limitations placed upon women within the context of early 20th-century American aristocracy. The East Egg setting, an enclave of "old money," provides the geographical and social backdrop against which Tom Buchanan's actions unfold, highlighting the insular and often destructive nature of his privileged world.

Image taken from the YouTube channel MOMENTOS , from the video titled The Great Gatsby (2013) - Nick`s Visit to Buchanan's House Scene (2/40) | Momentos .

Tom Buchanan: The Antagonist of the American Dream

Tom Buchanan stands as a towering figure in F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby, a man whose presence looms large over the narrative and its themes.

He is not merely a character, but an embodiment of the aristocratic elite during the Roaring Twenties. Through Tom, Fitzgerald offers a searing critique of the American Dream.

Tom embodies the very antithesis of the ideals of upward mobility and self-made success.

Introducing the Antagonist

From his first appearance, Tom is established as a man of immense wealth and power, a former football star whose physical strength mirrors his social dominance.

He is the quintessential "old money" archetype, secure in his inherited privilege and deeply contemptuous of those who seek to challenge the established order.

The Essence of Fitzgerald's Critique: A Thesis

Tom Buchanan embodies the entrenched privilege, moral decay, and destructive tendencies of the American aristocracy during the Roaring Twenties.

He serves as a critical lens through which Fitzgerald critiques the illusion of the American Dream, exposing its corruption and ultimate unattainability for those outside the elite circle.

Through Tom, Fitzgerald reveals the dark underbelly of an era defined by excess and superficiality.

He unveils how the pursuit of wealth and status can lead to moral bankruptcy and the destruction of genuine human connection.

Tom's character serves as a stark warning against the allure of the American Dream when it is pursued at the expense of integrity and compassion.

East Egg and the Entrenchment of "Old Money"

Building upon the introduction of Tom Buchanan, it's crucial to understand the environment that molded him: East Egg. This geographical location within the narrative isn't merely a setting; it's a potent symbol of entrenched wealth, established social order, and the almost unbreachable walls of "old money" society.

East Egg: A Bastion of Tradition

East Egg represents the established aristocracy, those families whose fortunes were built generations ago, granting them an almost untouchable social status. It's a world where lineage matters more than achievement, and where wealth is a birthright, not a reward for effort.

This is in stark contrast to West Egg, the home of "new money" like Jay Gatsby, where fortunes were often made more recently and through less conventional means.

The Buchanan Mansion: Opulence as a Statement

The physical embodiment of Tom's privilege is his mansion, a grand estate that exudes wealth and power. The descriptions of the Buchanan's home emphasize its extravagance, from the sweeping lawns to the lavishly decorated interior.

Every detail serves as a visual reminder of the Buchanan's elevated position within society. It’s a symbol of stability, permanence, and the seemingly unshakeable foundation of their inherited fortune.

Old Money vs. New Money: The Uncrossable Divide

Fitzgerald masterfully portrays the deep chasm between East Egg and West Egg, highlighting the disdain with which "old money" views those who have newly acquired their wealth. Tom embodies this prejudice, viewing Gatsby and his ilk with a mixture of suspicion and contempt.

He sees Gatsby's lavish parties not as a celebration of success, but as a vulgar display, a desperate attempt to buy his way into a world to which he doesn't truly belong. This social hierarchy is deeply ingrained.

It protects the established elite from any perceived threats from the nouveau riche.

Polo Ponies: Symbols of Aristocratic Leisure

Even seemingly minor details, like Tom's polo ponies, contribute to the portrayal of his aristocratic background. Polo is a sport traditionally associated with the wealthy elite.

It’s a symbol of leisure, privilege, and the kind of upbringing that is simply unattainable for those outside of that social circle. The ponies represent a life of effortless privilege, far removed from the struggles and ambitions of those in West Egg.

The Entitlement of Privilege

Ultimately, Tom's connection to East Egg grants him a level of privilege that extends far beyond mere material wealth. He operates with a sense of entitlement.

He is confident that he can evade the consequences of his actions, a belief born from a lifetime of being shielded by his family's wealth and social standing.

This includes his blatant infidelity, his casual racism, and his destructive behavior towards those around him.

This privilege is the bedrock of his character, shaping his worldview and enabling him to perpetuate the cycle of inequality and moral decay that Fitzgerald so vividly portrays.

Moral Bankruptcy: Infidelity, Materialism, and Toxic Masculinity

Following the examination of Tom's privileged background, it's impossible to ignore the profound moral decay at his core. This decay manifests in his blatant infidelity, obsessive materialism, and domineering displays of toxic masculinity. These traits aren't mere imperfections; they are fundamental to his character and reveal the rotten underbelly of the American Dream as embodied by the wealthy elite.

Tom's Infidelity and the Decadence of the Elite

Tom's affair with Myrtle Wilson is perhaps the most visible symptom of his moral sickness. It's not simply a transgression against his marriage vows; it's a demonstration of his profound disrespect for women and his belief that he is entitled to anything he desires, regardless of the consequences.

Myrtle is treated as a possession, a plaything to satisfy his carnal desires, and then easily discarded when she becomes inconvenient. This callous disregard for human life underscores the moral bankruptcy of the wealthy class, who often view others as disposable objects in their pursuit of pleasure.

New York City: A Stage for Immorality

New York City serves as a fitting backdrop for Tom's illicit activities. The city's frenetic energy and opulent displays of wealth create an environment where moral boundaries blur, and indulgence reigns supreme.

Tom's affair unfolds against this backdrop, further emphasizing the sense of detachment and moral ambiguity that permeates the lives of the wealthy. The city becomes a playground for their excesses, a place where consequences seem distant and accountability is easily avoided.

The Grip of Materialism

Materialism is a pervasive theme throughout The Great Gatsby, and Tom is a prime example of its corrupting influence. His life revolves around the accumulation of wealth and possessions, which he uses to assert his dominance and maintain his social standing.

The obsession with material goods extends beyond Tom himself, influencing the desires and aspirations of those around him, particularly Daisy.

Diamonds and the Currency of Love

The allure of diamonds and jewelry symbolizes Daisy's own material desires and Tom's ability to provide for them. He uses these opulent gifts as a means of control, reinforcing Daisy's dependence on him and solidifying his position of power within their relationship.

This transactional view of love, where affection is measured in terms of material wealth, reveals the emptiness and superficiality that lie beneath the glittering surface of the wealthy class.

Toxic Masculinity and the Assertion of Power

Tom's masculinity is defined by aggression, dominance, and a need to control those around him. He is physically imposing and often resorts to displays of strength and intimidation to assert his authority.

This toxic masculinity is not only harmful to those around him, particularly the women in his life, but it also reveals his own insecurities and vulnerabilities. His need to constantly prove himself suggests a deep-seated fear of inadequacy.

Cars: Symbols of Wealth and Destruction

Cars in The Great Gatsby are more than just modes of transportation; they are symbols of wealth, status, and, ultimately, destruction. Tom's possession of powerful and expensive automobiles reinforces his image as a man of power and influence.

However, the novel also links cars to recklessness and tragedy, most notably in Myrtle's death. This event highlights the destructive potential of unchecked wealth and the careless disregard for human life that often accompanies it. The car, in this context, embodies Tom's destructive tendencies and the devastating consequences of his actions.

Racism and Social Arrogance: Unmasking Tom Buchanan's Prejudice

Following the examination of Tom's privileged background, it's impossible to ignore the profound moral decay at his core. This decay manifests in his blatant infidelity, obsessive materialism, and domineering displays of toxic masculinity. These traits aren't mere imperfections; they are symptomatic of a deeper, more insidious prejudice that permeates his worldview. Tom's casually expressed racism and unshakeable sense of social superiority reveal a character deeply entrenched in the discriminatory ideologies of his time, solidifying his role as a key figure in Fitzgerald's critique of the American Dream's inherent flaws.

The Casual Bigotry of the Elite

Tom Buchanan's racism isn't presented as an explicit, hateful ideology. Instead, it surfaces through casual remarks and a disturbing acceptance of pseudoscientific theories. He unflinchingly parrots ideas rooted in white supremacist thought, showcasing the insidious nature of prejudice within the upper echelons of society. His reference to "The Rise of the Colored Empires" demonstrates how deeply ingrained racist ideologies were, shaping the perspectives and prejudices of the wealthy elite.

This wasn't just a personal failing; it was indicative of a broader societal problem, where discriminatory beliefs were normalized and perpetuated within influential circles. Tom's nonchalant delivery of these views underscores the danger of unexamined privilege, where harmful ideologies are readily embraced and disseminated without critical evaluation.

The Arrogance of Inherited Status

Beyond racial prejudice, Tom exudes an overwhelming sense of social arrogance stemming from his inherited wealth and elite status. He believes himself inherently superior to those he deems beneath him, a belief that fuels his dismissive attitude towards those outside his social circle. His interactions with George Wilson, for instance, are marked by condescension and a blatant disregard for Wilson's humanity.

Tom sees Wilson not as an equal, but as a means to an end – a convenient facilitator for his affair with Myrtle. This dehumanization reflects a profound lack of empathy, highlighting the corrosive effects of unchecked privilege and the ease with which the wealthy can exploit those less fortunate.

Textual Evidence of Superiority

Fitzgerald masterfully weaves subtle details into Tom's dialogue and actions to reveal his deeply ingrained superiority complex. His booming voice, physical dominance, and tendency to interrupt and talk over others all contribute to a portrait of a man accustomed to being in control and having his opinions unchallenged.

One striking example is his treatment of Gatsby. Despite Gatsby's immense wealth, Tom consistently undermines him, reminding him (and everyone else) of his "new money" status and lack of social pedigree. This isn't merely a rivalry; it's a calculated attempt to maintain his position atop the social hierarchy.

His volatile temper and willingness to resort to physical violence further underscore his sense of entitlement. He believes he is above the law, both literally and figuratively, and that his social status grants him the right to impose his will on others. This disregard for consequences reinforces the idea that the wealthy elite operate within a different set of rules than the rest of society.

The Corrupted Dream: Tom's Privilege vs. Gatsby's Pursuit

Following the exploration of Tom's ingrained racism and social arrogance, it's crucial to examine how his character dismantles the very notion of the American Dream. Tom's inherited privilege stands in stark contrast to Gatsby's relentless striving, illuminating the unattainable and often corrupt nature of chasing an ideal in a society stratified by wealth and status. Tom's actions, born from his privileged position, actively contribute to the disillusionment that pervades the novel, particularly in the context of relationships and human value.

The Illusion of Opportunity

The American Dream, at its core, promises upward mobility and the possibility of achieving success regardless of one's origins.

However, Fitzgerald uses Tom Buchanan to expose the fallacy of this promise, particularly for those born into wealth. Tom's privilege isn't earned; it's inherited, a birthright that grants him access to power, social standing, and the ability to manipulate those around him.

This inherited advantage directly undermines the concept of a level playing field, making Gatsby's pursuit—a self-made man striving for acceptance and love—seem almost futile in comparison.

The contrast between Tom and Gatsby highlights the inherent inequalities within the American social structure, revealing that true opportunity is often an illusion, particularly when pitted against the entrenched power of "old money."

Daisy Buchanan: A Trophy of Wealth and Status

Daisy Buchanan becomes a central figure in the corruption of the American Dream. She represents not just Gatsby's personal desire, but also the allure of a certain lifestyle, a symbol of achieving the highest echelons of society.

Tom possesses Daisy by birthright, while Gatsby relentlessly pursues her as the ultimate validation of his success.

This dynamic exposes the superficiality and moral decay within their relationships. Daisy, trapped between Tom's established wealth and Gatsby's newfound fortune, embodies the internal conflict of choosing security over passion, ultimately succumbing to the societal pressures that favor Tom's inherited power.

The relationships surrounding Daisy, including Jordan Baker, are mired in superficiality. They emphasize the corrupting influence of wealth on genuine human connection.

Daisy's choices reflect the ultimate disillusionment of the American Dream: that true happiness cannot be bought or achieved through material possessions or social status alone.

Myrtle Wilson: A Casualty of Disregard

Myrtle Wilson serves as a tragic example of the disregard for human life fueled by wealth and social standing.

Tom's treatment of Myrtle as a disposable object underscores the moral bankruptcy that accompanies his privilege.

He views her as a means of satisfying his desires, devoid of genuine affection or respect. Myrtle's aspirations, her yearning for a better life, are brutally crushed by Tom's callous actions, epitomizing the destructive consequences of unchecked power and the exploitation of those deemed socially inferior.

Her death, a direct result of reckless behavior enabled by wealth, symbolizes the ultimate failure of the American Dream for those relegated to the margins of society.

Tom's Tangled Web: Relationships with Key Characters

Following the exploration of Tom's ingrained racism and social arrogance, it's crucial to examine how his character dismantles the very notion of the American Dream. Tom's inherited privilege stands in stark contrast to Gatsby's relentless striving, illuminating the unattainable and often corrupt nature of the dream itself. To truly understand Tom Buchanan, one must dissect the complex web of relationships he weaves with those around him, revealing the power dynamics, rivalries, and destructive influences that define his existence.

Gatsby: A Clash of Worlds

Tom views Gatsby as a threat, not just to his marriage, but to the established social order he represents. Gatsby's "new money," earned through means Tom deems questionable, challenges the exclusivity of the East Egg elite.

Their contrasting backgrounds – Tom's inherited wealth versus Gatsby's self-made fortune – highlight the deep-seated prejudices and anxieties of the old aristocracy.

Tom's animosity towards Gatsby is fueled by jealousy and a fear of losing control over Daisy.

He is determined to expose Gatsby's true origins and undermine his carefully constructed facade. This rivalry becomes a battleground for the soul of Daisy and the validation of their respective worldviews.

Daisy: A Prisoner of Privilege

The relationship between Tom and Daisy is a chilling depiction of power imbalances and societal constraints. Daisy is essentially a prisoner of her own privilege, trapped in a loveless marriage by the expectations of her social class and her own material desires.

Tom exerts control through his wealth, social standing, and sheer force of will.

Daisy, though aware of Tom's infidelity and moral failings, lacks the agency to break free from the gilded cage he provides.

Her subjugation is not merely a result of Tom's dominance; it's a reflection of the limited options available to women of her social standing in the Roaring Twenties.

Jordan Baker: Complicity and Convenience

Jordan Baker, a professional golfer and a close friend of Daisy, represents the moral ambiguity and complicity prevalent within the wealthy class.

She is aware of Tom's affair and Daisy's unhappiness, yet she remains entrenched in their world, benefiting from its luxuries and accepting its moral compromises.

Jordan's connection to Tom and Daisy underscores the insular nature of their social circle, where appearances are valued above genuine connection and loyalty. She navigates this world with a cynical detachment, prioritizing her own self-interest over ethical considerations.

Nick Carraway: An Outsider's Perspective

Nick Carraway, the narrator of The Great Gatsby, provides a crucial outsider's perspective on Tom and his world.

Initially drawn to the allure of wealth and status, Nick gradually becomes disillusioned by the moral decay and superficiality he witnesses.

Through Nick's eyes, we see Tom's arrogance, cruelty, and ultimate culpability in the tragic events that unfold.

Nick's eventual rejection of the East Egg society serves as a moral judgment on the corrupting influence of wealth and privilege.

He represents the possibility of choosing integrity over social acceptance, even when faced with the seductive power of the elite.

George Wilson: A Victim of Recklessness

George Wilson, Myrtle's husband, embodies the plight of the working class and the devastating consequences of Tom's recklessness.

Tom's affair with Myrtle leads to her tragic death, which in turn sets in motion a chain of events that culminates in Gatsby's murder.

Wilson represents the forgotten and marginalized, those who are crushed beneath the weight of the wealthy elite's indifference.

Tom's disregard for Wilson's humanity highlights the callousness and social irresponsibility that define his character.

Video: Tom Buchanan: Wealth, Power, & Impact in Gatsby

Play Video

So, there you have it – a glimpse into the complex character that is Tom Buchanan. He's not a simple villain, but a product of his time, his privilege, and his own deeply flawed nature. Whether you see him as a cautionary tale or simply a necessary force in the unfolding tragedy of Gatsby, one thing's for sure: Tom Buchanan leaves a lasting, and undeniably impactful, mark on the story.