Maned Wolf Consumer Level: Ethical Pet? Conservation?

The debate surrounding the Chrysocyon brachyurus, commonly known as the Maned Wolf, intensifies as its unusual charm sparks interest beyond wildlife sanctuaries, prompting questions about the ethical considerations of its potential entry into the consumer market. Conservation organizations, such as the IUCN, emphasize the vulnerability of this South American canid, whose fragile populations face mounting threats from habitat loss and human encroachment, making the prospect of these animals entering the maned wolf consumer level deeply concerning. This concern intersects with ongoing discussions within zoological ethics regarding the commodification of wild animals, particularly focusing on whether the welfare of a species can be adequately protected if they are traded as pets, a question that requires careful consideration of the long-term impacts on both individual animals and the stability of wild populations. The complexities of wildlife trade regulations, exemplified by CITES, further complicate the issue, highlighting the legal and moral ambiguities that arise when considering whether the maned wolf should ever be regarded as a consumer product.

Image taken from the YouTube channel BBC Earth , from the video titled The Rare and Elusive Maned Wolf | How Nature Works | BBC Earth .

The Maned Wolf and the Exotic Pet Trade: A Conservation Crossroads

The maned wolf (Chrysocyon brachyurus), a striking canid native to the grasslands and scrublands of South America, stands apart. Its stilt-like legs, fox-like face, and reddish-orange coat make it an evolutionary oddity, the sole member of its genus. Currently listed as Near Threatened by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN), the maned wolf faces a multitude of threats, including habitat loss, road mortality, and persecution by humans.

Understanding the Maned Wolf: Natural History and Conservation

The maned wolf's unique morphology is an adaptation to its environment. Its long legs allow it to see over tall grasses, aiding in the detection of prey. This creature is an omnivore, consuming small mammals, birds, reptiles, fruits, and vegetables. Maned wolves typically form monogamous pairs that share a territory, though they primarily hunt alone.

The maned wolf's conservation status reflects the precarious position it holds in a rapidly changing world. Habitat loss due to agricultural expansion and urbanization is a primary driver of population decline. Encounters with vehicles on roadways are also a significant source of mortality. Furthermore, misconceptions about the animal, leading to its persecution by farmers who fear for their livestock, exacerbate the threats it faces.

Conservation efforts are underway across its range, focusing on habitat protection, mitigating human-wildlife conflict, and raising public awareness. However, a new, potentially insidious threat looms on the horizon: the exotic pet trade.

A Nascent Threat: The Exotic Pet Trade

While not currently a widespread phenomenon, the prospect of maned wolves entering the exotic pet trade presents a complex challenge. The allure of owning a unique and "exotic" animal can drive demand, potentially leading to the capture and removal of individuals from wild populations, or the establishment of captive breeding programs with questionable ethical standards.

If maned wolves were to become a desirable commodity in the exotic pet market, the consequences for wild populations could be dire. The removal of even a small number of individuals could disrupt social structures, reduce genetic diversity, and further imperil a species already facing numerous challenges.

Therefore, this exploration addresses a critical juncture in maned wolf conservation: the potential entry of maned wolves into the exotic pet trade demands careful ethical and conservation considerations to proactively safeguard this unique species. This analysis will explore the ethical, ecological, and practical implications of such a scenario, aiming to inform a proactive and responsible approach to maned wolf conservation in the face of this emerging threat.

A Hypothetical Scenario: Maned Wolves as Exotic Pets

While currently uncommon, the possibility of maned wolves entering the exotic pet trade warrants careful consideration. Exploring this hypothetical scenario requires analyzing potential demand, the roles of breeders and retailers, the influence of online marketplaces, and the impact of international regulations, as well as weighing arguments for and against such a trade.

Gauging Potential Demand

The allure of owning a unique and exotic animal often fuels the exotic pet trade. The maned wolf, with its distinctive appearance and elusive nature, could attract individuals seeking a status symbol or a connection with the wild.

This demand could stem from various motivations, including fascination with the animal's unique morphology, a desire for prestige, or a genuine (though perhaps misguided) interest in conservation.

However, realistically assessing the potential demand requires acknowledging the specialized needs of maned wolves, which could deter many potential owners.

The Roles of Breeders and Retailers

If demand were to increase, exotic pet breeders and retailers could play a significant role in facilitating the trade. Captive breeding operations could be established, potentially sourcing animals from zoos or even, controversially, from the wild.

Retailers, both brick-and-mortar and online, could then market and sell maned wolves to interested buyers.

The involvement of these players raises concerns about the welfare of the animals, as profit motives could overshadow ethical considerations. Oversight is crucial to ensure humane treatment and prevent exploitation.

Online Platforms: A Double-Edged Sword

Online platforms could serve as both a marketplace and a source of information for those interested in maned wolves. Social media groups and online forums could connect buyers and sellers, while also providing a space for discussing care requirements and sharing experiences.

However, the anonymity and lack of regulation associated with online platforms could also facilitate illegal trade and the spread of misinformation. Verification and stringent oversight are necessary to prevent these negative consequences.

International Regulations: CITES and Beyond

The Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES) plays a crucial role in regulating the international trade of threatened and endangered species. Currently, the maned wolf is not listed on CITES Appendix I, which prohibits commercial trade, but it is important to ensure that it is not listed in the future.

Listing the maned wolf on CITES Appendix I would significantly restrict international trade, making it more difficult for individuals to acquire them as pets.

However, CITES only governs international trade, and domestic laws are also essential for regulating the ownership and breeding of exotic animals within individual countries.

Arguments For and Against Pet Ownership

The debate over whether maned wolves should be allowed in the pet trade is complex and multifaceted. Proponents might argue that captive breeding could reduce pressure on wild populations and that responsible owners could provide adequate care for these animals.

They might also emphasize the potential for educational opportunities and the personal fulfillment that could come from owning such a unique creature.

However, these arguments are often overshadowed by concerns about animal welfare, conservation, and public safety. Opponents would argue that maned wolves are not domesticated animals and that their specialized needs are difficult to meet in a domestic setting.

They would also point to the potential for negative impacts on wild populations, the risk of disease transmission, and the ethical implications of confining a wild animal for human entertainment. Given the current lack of evidence suggesting maned wolves are appropriate pets, the risks associated with this trade are substantial and deserve serious consideration.

Ethical Labyrinth: The Morality of Owning a Maned Wolf

While currently uncommon, the possibility of maned wolves entering the exotic pet trade warrants careful consideration. Exploring this hypothetical scenario requires analyzing potential demand, the roles of breeders and retailers, the influence of online marketplaces, and the impact of international regulations. However, beyond the practical considerations, lies a more profound question: Is it ethically justifiable to keep a maned wolf as a pet?

This section will delve into the ethical dimensions of such a decision.

We will explore this question through the lens of established ethical frameworks, analyze differing viewpoints from animal ethicists and organizations, and examine the influence of public opinion and cultural values on our perceptions of exotic pet ownership.

Ethical Frameworks: A Moral Compass

Applying ethical frameworks provides a structured approach to evaluating the morality of owning a maned wolf.

Utilitarianism, for example, focuses on maximizing overall happiness and minimizing suffering. In this context, a utilitarian argument would need to weigh the potential joy a maned wolf might bring to its owner against the potential suffering caused by removing it from its natural habitat, confining it to a domestic environment, and potentially contributing to the decline of wild populations.

Is the joy derived from ownership sufficient to outweigh the potential harm? It's a difficult calculation, prone to subjective valuations.

Conversely, deontology emphasizes moral duties and rules, regardless of consequences. A deontological perspective might argue that humans have a duty to respect the intrinsic value of all living beings and to avoid interfering with their natural lives.

Therefore, removing a maned wolf from its natural environment and subjecting it to domestication could be seen as a violation of this duty, regardless of how well the animal is treated in captivity.

Voices of Ethical Advocacy

Animal ethicists and animal rights organizations often advocate for a more biocentric or ecocentric view, emphasizing the inherent value of animals and ecosystems.

Their perspectives are crucial in shaping the ethical debate surrounding exotic pet ownership.

Many argue that wild animals, particularly those with complex social and behavioral needs like the maned wolf, are fundamentally unsuited to life in captivity.

They highlight the potential for psychological distress, behavioral abnormalities, and physical ailments that can arise from confinement and a lack of appropriate stimulation.

Moreover, they often point to the inherent power imbalance between humans and animals in a domestic setting, arguing that it is inherently exploitative and disrespectful.

Public Opinion and Cultural Context

Public attitudes towards exotic pet ownership are shaped by a complex interplay of factors, including cultural values, personal experiences, and media portrayals.

In some cultures, owning exotic animals may be seen as a status symbol or a display of wealth and power.

In others, there may be a greater emphasis on the welfare and conservation of wildlife.

The perception of an animal's "cuteness" or "desirability" can also significantly influence public opinion, potentially leading to increased demand for certain species as pets, irrespective of their suitability for domestication.

However, public awareness campaigns and educational initiatives can play a crucial role in shaping more informed and ethical attitudes towards exotic pet ownership, encouraging people to consider the complex ethical and conservation implications before acquiring a wild animal.

Ultimately, a deeper understanding of the ethical dimensions and ecological consequences could discourage many potential owners.

Conservation Consequences: Impacts on Wild Populations and Ecosystems

While currently uncommon, the possibility of maned wolves entering the exotic pet trade warrants careful consideration. Exploring this hypothetical scenario requires analyzing potential demand, the roles of breeders and retailers, the influence of online marketplaces, and the impact of international regulations.

The removal of maned wolves from their natural habitat to supply a potential exotic pet trade could have profound and far-reaching ecological and conservation consequences.

These impacts extend beyond just the immediate reduction in wild populations and can ripple through entire ecosystems, undermining decades of dedicated conservation efforts.

Direct Impact on Wild Populations

The most immediate and obvious consequence of a maned wolf pet trade would be the direct depletion of wild populations.

Even seemingly small numbers of individuals removed could have a significant impact, especially if those individuals are breeding adults or if the removals are concentrated in specific geographic areas.

Maned wolf populations are already fragmented and facing threats from habitat loss, agriculture, and road mortality.

Removing individuals for the pet trade exacerbates these existing pressures, potentially pushing local populations towards extinction.

Impacts on Conservation Organizations

Organizations dedicated to maned wolf conservation, often operating with limited resources, would face increased challenges.

They would be forced to divert resources towards combating illegal capture and trade, potentially hindering other crucial conservation activities such as habitat restoration and community engagement.

The need for increased monitoring and anti-poaching efforts would place a significant strain on already stretched budgets.

The Role of Zoos and SSPs

Zoos with breeding programs and Species Survival Plans (SSPs) play a crucial role in maintaining the genetic diversity of captive maned wolf populations.

However, these programs are not designed to supply a commercial pet trade.

Diverting individuals from SSPs to meet demand for pets would compromise the long-term genetic health and viability of captive populations, potentially undermining their value for future reintroduction efforts.

Captive breeding programs focus on conservation, education, and research, not commercial trade.

Any shift towards supplying a pet market would fundamentally alter the purpose and integrity of these programs.

Captive breeding and reintroduction programs are often seen as a last resort for species facing extinction. However, their success is not guaranteed.

Reintroducing captive-bred maned wolves into the wild is a complex and challenging undertaking, requiring careful planning, extensive monitoring, and significant financial investment.

If the demand for maned wolves as pets leads to the capture of wild individuals, it could undermine the success of ongoing or future reintroduction efforts.

The removal of individuals for the pet trade reduces the genetic diversity of the source population and could introduce diseases into wild populations.

Perspectives of Wildlife Biologists and Ecologists

Wildlife biologists and ecologists overwhelmingly oppose the removal of individuals from wild populations for the pet trade. Their concerns center on the potential for ecological disruption, the ethical implications of removing animals from their natural habitat, and the long-term consequences for species conservation.

Removing even a few individuals can disrupt social structures, reduce genetic diversity, and negatively impact the overall health and resilience of a population.

Consequences Such as Habitat Fragmentation, Road Mortality, and Poaching

Habitat fragmentation, road mortality, and poaching are already significant threats to maned wolf populations.

The emergence of a pet trade could exacerbate these threats by increasing the incentive for poaching and further fragmenting habitats to facilitate capture and transportation.

Increased Disease Transmission

The potential for increased disease transmission between captive and wild populations is a serious concern.

Captive animals may carry diseases that are not present in wild populations, and the introduction of these diseases could have devastating consequences for wild maned wolves.

Conversely, wild-caught individuals could introduce diseases into captive populations.

Strict quarantine and health screening protocols are essential to minimize the risk of disease transmission, but these measures are often difficult to enforce and may not be entirely effective.

Stakeholder Perspectives: Voices in the Debate

[Conservation Consequences: Impacts on Wild Populations and Ecosystems While currently uncommon, the possibility of maned wolves entering the exotic pet trade warrants careful consideration. Exploring this hypothetical scenario requires analyzing potential demand, the roles of breeders and retailers, the influence of online marketplaces, and the imp...]

The complex issue of maned wolf conservation involves a diverse range of stakeholders, each with unique perspectives and vested interests. Understanding these viewpoints is crucial for formulating effective and ethical conservation strategies. These stakeholders include government agencies, local communities, and animal welfare organizations.

Their concerns, responsibilities, and potential conflicts must be carefully considered when addressing the hypothetical, yet important, possibility of maned wolves in the exotic pet trade.

Governmental Responsibilities: A Balancing Act

The Brazilian government's environmental agencies bear the primary responsibility for protecting maned wolf populations within their natural habitat. This responsibility encompasses several key areas: enforcing existing wildlife protection laws, regulating any potential trade in maned wolves, and implementing conservation programs aimed at preserving their habitat.

Effective enforcement is often hampered by limited resources and the vastness of the maned wolf's range. Furthermore, the temptation for corruption and the prioritization of economic development over environmental protection can create significant challenges.

The government must strike a delicate balance between promoting sustainable development and safeguarding the long-term survival of this iconic species. The implementation of effective anti-poaching patrols and habitat protection measures are paramount. Transparent and accountable governance is essential for building trust with other stakeholders and ensuring the effectiveness of conservation efforts.

Local Communities: Living Alongside Maned Wolves

Local communities living in proximity to maned wolf habitats often face challenges related to livestock predation and competition for resources. These challenges can lead to negative perceptions of maned wolves and, in some cases, retaliatory killings.

Effective conservation strategies must involve engaging with local communities and addressing their concerns. This can be achieved through community-based conservation programs that provide economic incentives for protecting maned wolves.

Such programs can include ecotourism initiatives, compensation schemes for livestock losses, and education programs aimed at promoting coexistence. Understanding the local knowledge and traditional practices of these communities is crucial for developing culturally sensitive and effective conservation strategies.

Animal Welfare Organizations: Champions for Humane Treatment

Animal welfare organizations play a vital role in advocating for the humane treatment of maned wolves, both in the wild and in captivity. These organizations often raise awareness about the threats facing maned wolf populations and lobby for stronger legal protections.

They also work to rescue and rehabilitate injured or orphaned maned wolves, and to educate the public about the ethical considerations surrounding the ownership of exotic animals. The role of animal welfare organizations is crucial in ensuring the ethical treatment of these canids.

However, differing perspectives within the animal welfare community can sometimes create conflict. Some organizations may advocate for a strict ban on all forms of captive breeding and ownership, while others may support regulated breeding programs that contribute to conservation efforts. Navigating these different viewpoints is essential for developing a unified and effective approach to maned wolf conservation.

Legal and Regulatory Framework: Navigating the Legal Landscape

[Stakeholder Perspectives: Voices in the Debate [Conservation Consequences: Impacts on Wild Populations and Ecosystems While currently uncommon, the possibility of maned wolves entering the exotic pet trade warrants careful consideration. Exploring this hypothetical scenario requires analyzing potential demand, the roles of breeders and retailers, t...]

Understanding the existing legal and regulatory framework is crucial to preventing the entry of maned wolves into the exotic pet trade and ensuring their conservation. The legal landscape governing exotic animal ownership is complex, varying significantly across international borders, national jurisdictions, and even local municipalities. This section will examine the relevant legal structures.

The Patchwork of Exotic Animal Laws

The legal status of exotic animal ownership, including species like the maned wolf, is far from uniform.

Many countries and states have established regulations regarding the possession, breeding, and sale of exotic animals, but the specifics differ considerably.

Some jurisdictions implement a prohibited species list, which explicitly bans the ownership of certain animals deemed dangerous or detrimental to the environment. Other locations utilize a permit system, requiring individuals to obtain specific authorization to possess restricted species.

The absence of a standardized international framework creates loopholes. Loopholes could be exploited by those seeking to circumvent stricter regulations in one region by operating in a more permissive environment.

The lack of legal harmonization poses a significant challenge to effective conservation efforts.

The Role of Lawmakers and Enforcement Agencies

Lawmakers and legislators bear the responsibility of crafting clear, enforceable laws that address the potential risks associated with exotic animal ownership.

These laws must strike a balance between protecting animal welfare, safeguarding public safety, and acknowledging the rights of responsible animal owners.

Animal control agencies and law enforcement play a critical role in enforcing these regulations. Effective enforcement requires adequate resources, training, and collaboration between different agencies.

This includes the local police force and conservation authorities, as well as federal agencies.

The penalties for violating exotic animal ownership laws can range from fines and confiscation of animals to criminal charges. The severity of the penalties must be sufficient to deter illegal activity.

Navigating Legal Complexities: The Need for Expertise

The legal landscape surrounding exotic animal ownership can be intricate, often involving overlapping jurisdictions and conflicting regulations.

Navigating these complexities requires the expertise of legal professionals specializing in animal law and wildlife conservation. These experts can provide guidance on compliance with applicable laws, assess the legality of specific activities, and advocate for stronger protections for vulnerable species.

Furthermore, the lack of clarity in existing legislation often necessitates legal interpretation and judicial review. Legal challenges to exotic animal laws can clarify ambiguities and establish precedents that shape future regulations.

Legal experts can also contribute to the development of best practices for regulating exotic animal ownership, drawing on scientific evidence and ethical considerations.

The Importance of Proactive Legislation

Waiting for a crisis to occur before enacting protective legislation is a reactive approach that puts vulnerable species at risk.

Proactive legislation is essential to prevent maned wolves from entering the exotic pet trade. This should include strong regulations on the import, export, and sale of maned wolves, as well as measures to ensure their humane treatment in captivity.

Such proactive measures should have mechanisms in place to be updated as new scientific findings emerge and markets evolve.

The legal and regulatory framework must adapt to the ever-changing dynamics of the exotic animal trade. It should reflect a commitment to protecting biodiversity and ensuring the well-being of all animals.

Practical Realities: The Challenges of Caring for a Maned Wolf in Captivity

While currently uncommon, the possibility of maned wolves entering the exotic pet trade warrants careful consideration. Exploring this hypothetical scenario requires an understanding of the immense practical challenges involved in providing adequate care for these unique canids in a domestic environment.

The Demands of a Wild Heritage

The maned wolf, unlike domesticated dogs, is a creature of the South American grasslands. Their physiology, behavior, and nutritional needs are finely tuned to this environment.

Attempting to replicate such conditions in a typical household presents significant hurdles. Meeting their basic needs would require substantial resources, specialized knowledge, and unwavering dedication.

Dietary Dilemmas: Replicating a Natural Diet

Maned wolves are omnivores with a highly specialized diet. In the wild, they consume a mix of small mammals, birds, insects, and fruits, including the lobeira fruit, which is thought to play a crucial role in their kidney function.

Replicating this diet in captivity is exceptionally difficult. It requires sourcing specialized ingredients and carefully balancing nutrients.

Failure to provide an appropriate diet can lead to serious health problems, including nutritional deficiencies and organ damage.

Environmental Enrichment: Beyond the Backyard

These animals are adapted to roam vast territories. Confining them to a typical backyard deprives them of essential physical and mental stimulation.

Their natural behaviors, such as scent marking and digging, may be difficult to accommodate in a domestic setting. A lack of appropriate environmental enrichment can lead to stress, behavioral problems, and a decline in overall well-being.

Creating a suitable enclosure would require a significant investment of space and resources, far beyond the capabilities of most pet owners.

The Role of Specialized Veterinary Care

The unique physiology of maned wolves necessitates specialized veterinary care. Most general practice veterinarians lack the expertise to diagnose and treat health problems specific to this species.

Finding a veterinarian with experience in exotic animal medicine can be challenging, particularly in areas far from zoos or wildlife sanctuaries.

The cost of such specialized care can be substantial. This presents a significant barrier for many potential owners. Prompt and effective veterinary intervention is crucial for maintaining the health and welfare of these animals.

The Risk of Abandonment and the Burden on Shelters

Unfortunately, the realities of exotic pet ownership often lead to abandonment. Individuals may underestimate the commitment involved or find themselves unable to cope with the challenges of caring for a wild animal.

Animal shelters and rescues are ill-equipped to handle the specific needs of maned wolves. These facilities often lack the resources, expertise, and appropriate enclosures to provide adequate care.

The influx of abandoned maned wolves would place a significant strain on already overburdened animal welfare organizations. Finding suitable placement for these animals would be exceptionally difficult.

Zoonotic Disease Concerns

Maned wolves, like many wild animals, can carry zoonotic diseases that pose a risk to human health. These diseases can be transmitted through direct contact, bites, or exposure to contaminated environments.

The risk of zoonotic disease transmission is heightened in a domestic setting, where humans and animals live in close proximity. Adopting strict hygiene practices and seeking regular veterinary care is crucial to minimize these risks.

However, the potential for disease transmission remains a significant concern, particularly for vulnerable populations such as children and the elderly.

Solutions and Mitigation: Protecting Maned Wolves in the Wild

While currently uncommon, the possibility of maned wolves entering the exotic pet trade warrants careful consideration. Exploring this hypothetical scenario requires an understanding of the immense practical challenges involved in providing adequate care for these unique canids. Beyond these individual animal welfare concerns, proactive steps are crucial to prevent the maned wolf from becoming a target in the exotic animal market and to bolster the conservation of wild populations. A multi-pronged approach, combining robust international regulations, habitat protection, public education, and strategic conservation investments, is paramount.

Strengthening Legal Frameworks

The cornerstone of preventing maned wolves from entering the exotic pet trade lies in strengthening international and national legal frameworks. The Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES) plays a pivotal role in regulating the trade of threatened species.

However, enforcement remains a significant challenge.

Stricter regulations and increased resources for enforcement are necessary to effectively combat illegal trafficking.

Additionally, national laws in countries within the maned wolf's range, particularly Brazil, Argentina, Bolivia, Paraguay, and Uruguay, must be robust and consistently enforced. These laws should address not only international trade but also domestic possession and breeding.

Harmonizing legal standards across these countries could create a more unified and effective deterrent.

Safeguarding Habitats and Combating Poaching

Preserving and restoring maned wolf habitats is critical for the long-term survival of the species in the wild. This involves a range of strategies, including:

• Establishing and effectively managing protected areas.
• Promoting sustainable land use practices in agricultural areas.
• Connecting fragmented habitats through corridors.

Beyond habitat loss, direct persecution through poaching poses a serious threat. Increased investment in anti-poaching units and community-based conservation programs is essential.

Empowering local communities to become stewards of maned wolf conservation can foster a sense of ownership and reduce human-wildlife conflict.

Public Awareness and Education

A crucial component of any preventative strategy is raising public awareness about the realities of owning a maned wolf and the importance of conserving the species in its natural habitat. Many potential exotic pet owners are simply unaware of the complex needs and ethical considerations associated with keeping such animals.

Public awareness campaigns can effectively communicate the specialized dietary, environmental, and behavioral requirements of maned wolves, highlighting the difficulties of meeting these needs in a domestic setting.

These campaigns should also emphasize the conservation implications of removing maned wolves from the wild and the potential for zoonotic disease transmission. Collaborations with zoos, wildlife organizations, and media outlets can amplify the reach and impact of these educational efforts.

Strategic Conservation Investments and Cost-Benefit Analysis

Effective conservation requires strategic allocation of resources. A rigorous cost-benefit analysis of different conservation strategies is essential to prioritize actions that offer the greatest return on investment.

This analysis should consider not only the direct costs of implementing various strategies but also the potential benefits in terms of:

• Population recovery.
• Habitat restoration.
• Ecosystem services.
• Reduced human-wildlife conflict.

For example, investing in habitat restoration may provide long-term benefits for maned wolf populations and other species. While also supporting local communities through ecotourism opportunities.

Comparing the costs and benefits of different approaches can inform evidence-based decision-making and ensure that conservation efforts are both effective and sustainable.

Video: Maned Wolf Consumer Level: Ethical Pet? Conservation?

Play Video

So, where does that leave us with the whole maned wolf consumer level question? Probably best to admire these lanky canids from afar, supporting conservation efforts, and leaving them to roam those beautiful South American grasslands. They're much better suited to that life than becoming someone's quirky pet, and honestly, we should all be advocating for that kind of ethical interaction.